Published on: 16 July 2023 at 12:40 IST
Court: Supreme Court
Citation: Sridevi V. Jayaraja Shetty (2005)
Honourable Supreme Court of India has held that the Propounder of the Will has an Onus to prove that the Testator was in sound disposing state of mind and completely understood contents of the Will which is executed in his own free will. Further the Propounder of the Will has to prove that the said Will was signed were in the presence of the two witnesses.
14. The propounder of the Will has to show that the Will was signed by the testator; that he was at the relevant time in sound disposing state of mind; that he understood the nature and effect of dispositions and had put his signatures to the testament of his own free will and that he had signed it in the presence of the two witnesses who attested in his presence and in the presence of each other. Once these elements are established, the onus which rests on the propounder is discharged. DW 2, the scribe, in his testimony has categorically stated that the Will was scribed by him at the dictation of the testator.
The two attesting witnesses have deposed that the testator had signed the Will in their presence while in sound disposing state of mind after understanding the nature and effect of dispositions made by him. That he signed the Will in their presence and they had signed the Will in his presence and in the presence of each other. In cross-examination, the appellants failed to elicit anything which could persuade us to disbelieve their testimony. It has not been shown that they were in any way interested in the propounders of the Will or that on their asking they could have deposed falsely in court. Their testimony inspires confidence.
The testimony of the scribe (DW 2) and the two attesting witnesses (DWs 3 and 4) is fully corroborated by the statement of the handwriting expert (DW 5). The Will runs into 6 pages. The testator had signed each of the 6 pages. The handwriting expert compared the signatures of the testator with his admitted signatures. He has opined that the signatures on the Will are that of the testator. In our view, the Will had been duly executed.
Drafted By Abhijit Mishra
