Understanding Multi-Level Marketing and Its Regulation in India

By Md. Arif Imam

Published on: January 8, 2024 at 16:38 IST

Multi-Level Marketing (MLM), also known as Network Marketing, has emerged as a dynamic and often debated business model in the contemporary Indian market. This model, blending the traditional methods of direct sales with a unique hierarchical commission system which has attracted a vast array of individuals and companies, drawn by its promise of profitability and entrepreneurial opportunity. However, alongside its growth and popularity, MLM in India has also been a subject of controversy and legal scrutiny.

This business model operates on the principle of recruiting individuals to sell products or services, where the earnings are not only from personal sales but also from the sales of recruits, forming a multi-tiered structure. This structure is often misunderstood and conflated with illegal pyramid or Ponzi schemes, leading to significant legal and ethical questions.

The Indian market, with its vast and diverse consumer base, presents a fertile ground for MLM businesses. Products ranging from health supplements to lifestyle and beauty products are commonly marketed through this model. The appeal of MLM in India also lies in its alignment with the aspirations of a growing middle class, looking for supplementary income opportunities.

However, the regulatory environment in India for MLM has been evolving. The legal framework governing these businesses includes various laws and guidelines aimed at protecting the consumer while ensuring fair practices by MLM companies. The introduction of the Direct Selling Guidelines in 2016 was a significant step in this direction, providing clarity and legitimacy to MLM operations while aiming to eradicate the fraudulent practices.

The Indian judiciary has also played an important role in defining the legal status of MLM practices. Various landmark cases and rulings have provided insights into what constitutes legitimate network marketing activities versus illegal pyramid or money circulation schemes.

What is MLM or Network Marketing?

Multi-Level Marketing (MLM) or Network Marketing is a business model that relies on a network of distributors to grow a company’s products and services. In this structure, distributors earn income through direct sales of products or services and by recruiting new distributors. The recruited distributors are referred to as the original distributor’s “downline,” and commissions are earned based on sales made by the downline.^[1]

Key Characteristics of MLM:

1. Hierarchical Structure: MLM operates on multiple levels of distributors and recruits, forming a hierarchical network. Each level earns a commission on sales made by individuals in the level below them.
2. Recruitment Focus: A significant aspect of MLM is the emphasis on recruiting new members. Success in MLM often depends not just on product sales but also on the ability to build a robust downline network.
3. Direct Sales: Products or services are sold directly to consumers, often bypassing traditional retail environments. Distributors usually utilize personal networks and connections to make sales.
4. Earnings and Commissions: Distributors earn through direct sales and a percentage of sales made by their downlines. The potential for earning increases with a larger and more active downline.
5. Training and Support: MLM companies often provide training and support to their distributors, equipping them with the skills to sell products and recruit effectively.

Companies That Follow MLM Business Model

MLM business model can be found in a diverse range of industries which offers various products and services. Some well-known sectors include:

1. Health and Wellness: This sector is prevalent in the MLM, featuring products like dietary supplements, weight loss aids, and nutritional items.
2. Beauty and Personal Care: Another significant sector, this includes skincare, cosmetics, hair care products, and other personal care items.
3. Home and Lifestyle Products: These can range from cleaning supplies to home décor and kitchenware.
4. Financial Services and Insurance: Some MLM business model companies offer financial products, insurance policies, and investment plans.
5. Technology and Communications: This includes tech gadgets, software, and telecommunication services.

Examples of MLM Business Model Companies:

• Amway: One of the most recognized MLM companies globally, Amway sells health, beauty, and home care products.
• Herbalife: Known for its weight management and nutritional supplements, Herbalife is a global name in the MLM sector.
• Tupperware: Specializing in kitchen and home products, Tupperware is famous for its direct selling strategy.
• Avon: A leader in beauty and cosmetics, Avon relies heavily on its network of individual sales representatives.
• Oriflame: A beauty company that sells skin care and cosmetic products through its MLM network.

Each of these companies has a unique approach to MLM, with varied product offerings and marketing strategies. They rely on their networks of independent distributors to reach customers, often leveraging personal relationships and social networks.

Exposing Hidden Dangers: Understanding Illegal MLM Schemes

In the realm of multi-level marketing, appearances can be deceiving. This section sheds light on the hidden dangers of illegal MLM practices, offering a clear and straightforward examination. We aim to uncover the risks and true nature of these deceptive schemes, providing essential knowledge to help distinguish them from legitimate opportunities. The most common illegal schemes include money circulation schemes, pyramid schemes, illegal chit funds, and Ponzi schemes. Each of these has distinct characteristics and poses various risks to participants.

• Money Circulation Schemes: This type of Schemes typically promises quick financial returns, primarily based on recruiting new members rather than selling legitimate products or services. The primary income for participants in these schemes is generated from the fees or investments made by newly recruited members. These schemes are unsustainable as they rely on continuous recruitment for success and often collapse once the influx of new members slows down. They usually violate legal statutes against unregulated financial operations and are considered fraudulent.
• Pyramid Schemes: These are closely related to money circulation schemes but with a more defined structure where the main revenue is generated through new recruitments. They often present themselves as legitimate MLM opportunities but differ fundamentally in their operation. Instead of focusing on actual sales of products or services, they emphasize on recruiting more participants. The unsustainable nature of these schemes guarantees their eventual collapse when recruitment becomes unfeasible, leading to the loss for the majority of the participants.
• Chit Funds: Chit funds can be legal, but many operate without adhering to legal standards. In a typical chit fund, members contribute to a pooled fund, which is then allocated to individual members based on specific terms, often determined by auction or lottery. However, illegal chit funds lack regulatory oversight and transparency, leading to fraudulent activities and financial loss for the members. These illegal funds often circumvent the regulations set by the Chit Fund Act in India, resulting in scams and mismanagement of funds.
• Ponzi Schemes: These Schemes are investment scams that offer high returns over short periods. The catch in these schemes is that the returns to the earlier investors are paid out from the investments made by newer investors, rather than from profit earned by the person or organization running the operation. This type of scheme is destined to fail once the flow of new investors stops, leading to massive losses for most of the participants.

Legal Provisions Regulating MLM in India

India’s approach to regulating MLM and network marketing is multifaceted, involving various legal statutes and regulatory guidelines. These laws are designed to protect consumers and ensure fair practices in the industry. The primary legal provisions include:

1. The Prize Chits and Money Circulation Schemes (Banning) Act, 1978: This Act is aimed specifically at prohibiting any scheme that involves money circulation or enrolling members in exchange for a monetary return. It serves as an important legal tool against pyramid and Ponzi schemes, which often present themselves as legitimate MLM practices.
2. The Consumer Protection Act, 2019: The Consumer Protection Act, 2019: This act offers a wide range of measures for consumer rights and protection, which includes safeguards against deceptive marketing practices commonly found in illegitimate MLM schemes. It gives consumers the power to lodge complaints and seek solutions for issues related to unfair trade practices.
3. Direct Selling Guidelines 2016: Direct Selling Guidelines has been Issued by the Ministry of Consumer Affairs, these guidelines were a significant step in recognizing and differentiating legitimate direct selling (including MLM) from fraudulent schemes. They mandate clear identification, transparent business practices, and a grievance redressal mechanism for direct selling entities.
4. Companies Act, 2013: This act governs the incorporation, regulation, and dissolution of companies in India. MLM businesses, like all other companies, must adhere to its provisions, ensuring corporate accountability and transparency.
5. Income Tax Act, 1961: MLM participants are subject to income tax under this Act. It ensures that earnings from MLM activities are legally accounted for and taxed appropriately.
6. Foreign Exchange Management Act (FEMA): MLM companies engaging in cross-border activities must comply with FEMA regulations, particularly in terms of foreign payments and investments.

These laws collectively create a legal environment that aims to safeguard participants’ interests in MLM while curbing illegal activities under the guise of network marketing. MLM companies operating in India must align their business models with these regulations to ensure their operations are legal and sustainable.

Case Laws and Judgments in MLM in India

The Indian judiciary has dealt with several cases concerning MLM and Network Marketing, providing clarity on what constitutes a legal MLM operation and what falls under illegal schemes. Here are some notable cases:

1. Amway India Enterprises vs. Union of India (Case No. 20471 of 2006):
   • The Supreme Court observed that Amway’s scheme, which provided faster returns to distributors, was categorized as a ‘Money Circulation Scheme,‘ thus falling under illegal activities as per the Direct Selling Guidelines 2016 issued by the Ministry of Corporate Affairs. The judgement of the Hon’ble Supreme Court was based on Guidelines issued by Ministry of Corporate Affairs for Direct Selling Enterprises.^[2]
2. Kuriachan Chacko vs. State of Kerala (Case No. 17283 of 2016):
   • A partnership firm, M/S Ernakulam, introduced a lottery scheme named LIS Deepasthambham, where an investment of Rs 625 doubled by purchasing lottery tickets. The Supreme Court held that the scheme comes under cheating and illegal multi-level marketing, punishable under section 420 read with section 34 of the IPC.
3. State of Bengal vs. Swapan Kr. Guha, Sanchita Investments:
   • This case involved a partnership firm in the investment and finance business, accused of running a money circulation scheme. However, the Supreme Court held that the activities did not fall under section 2(c) of the Prize Chits and Money Circulation Schemes (Banning) Act of 1978, clearing the allegations made in the FIR.
4. M/S Apple FMCG Marketing Pvt. Ltd. vs. Union of India:
   • M/S Apple FMCG Marketing Pvt. Ltd. sought legal validation for their network marketing model. The Court found that the scheme, despite being presented as a multi-level marketing strategy, was essentially a money circulation scheme, with most earnings derived from enrolling new members rather than selling products. Hence, it was prohibited under the Act.

These cases highlight the fine line between legal MLM practices and those that are deemed illegal. They underscore the importance of a product or service-based revenue model in MLM, as opposed to schemes primarily focusing on recruitment for income generation. These judgments serve as a guide for businesses and individuals engaged in or considering MLM, ensuring compliance with legal standards and protection from illegal schemes.

How to Identify Legal Multi-Level Marketing (MLM) Companies

Distinguishing legal MLM operations from illegal ones is crucial for anyone looking to engage in network marketing. Here are some guidelines to help identify whether a company follows legal MLM practices:

1. Product Focus: Legal MLM companies focus on selling genuine products or services. Their revenue primarily comes from sales to the end consumer, not just from recruiting new members.
2. Investment Returns: If a company promises high returns in a short period, especially if these returns are not linked to product sales, it’s a red flag. Legal MLMs offer earnings based on actual sales performance.
3. Buy-in Costs: Be cautious of companies that require a high initial investment or purchase of expensive starter kits. Legal MLMs may have a small start-up cost, but it’s usually reasonable and linked to the product.
4. Training and Support: Legitimate MLM companies provide training and support to their distributors. This includes product knowledge, sales training, and marketing strategies.
5. Transparent Business Practices: Genuine MLM companies are transparent about their business model, compensation plan, and income disclosures. They comply with legal requirements and are open about their financials.
6. No Emphasis on Recruitment: While recruitment is a part of MLM, legal companies do not solely focus on this aspect. They emphasize product sales and have a reasonable compensation plan for sales versus recruitment.
7. Compliance with Direct Selling Guidelines: In India, legal MLM companies comply with the Direct Selling Guidelines 2016. These guidelines provide a framework for distinguishing legitimate direct selling from pyramid schemes.
8. Reputation and Reviews: Research the company’s reputation. Look for reviews, testimonials, and any news articles or legal cases involving the company. A legitimate MLM will have a history of fair business practices and satisfied customers and distributors.

By considering these factors, individuals can make more informed decisions about joining or doing business with an MLM company. It’s always advisable to conduct thorough research and seek legal advice if there are any doubts about a company’s operations.

Conclusion

In conclusion, Multi-Level Marketing (MLM) or Network Marketing is a popular business model in India, involving the sale of products or services through a network of distributors. While it offers opportunities for entrepreneurship and income, it’s important to distinguish between legal MLM practices and illegal schemes like pyramid and Ponzi schemes. Legal MLM focuses on selling real products to customers, not just recruiting more people. The Indian government has put in place various laws and guidelines, like the Direct Selling Guidelines of 2016 and the Consumer Protection Act, to protect people from fraud and ensure fair business practices.

Several Court cases in India have helped to clarify what’s legal and what’s not in MLM. To avoid getting involved in illegal schemes, it’s important to look for companies that focus on selling products, don’t promise quick, high returns just for recruiting people, have reasonable start-up costs, provide proper training, are transparent about their business, and follow government guidelines.

Before joining any MLM, it’s wise to do thorough research, understand their business model, and possibly get legal advice. This way, people can make informed decisions and avoid falling into illegal and potentially harmful schemes.

1. multi-level-marketing
2. legality-of-multiLevel-marketing-in-india ↑