Law Insider India

Legal News, Current Trends and Legal Insight | Supreme Court of India and High Courts

State of Rajasthan Vs Raja Ram (2003)

2 min read
State of Rajasthan vs Raja Ram (2003) Law Insider

Honourable Supreme Court of India

State of Rajasthan v. Raja Ram (2003) 8 SCC 180

Honourable Supreme Court of India has held that if a true voluntary confession is made in a fit state of mind, can be relied upon by the court. It is held that any confession will have to be proved like any other fact as the value of the evidence as to confession, like any other evidence, depends upon the veracity of the witness to whom it has been made.

Para 19. An extra-judicial confession, if voluntary and true and made in a fit state of mind, can be relied upon by the court. The confession will have to be proved like any other fact. The value of the evidence as to confession, like any other evidence, depends upon the veracity of the witness to whom it has been made. The value of the evidence as to the confession depends on the reliability of the witness who gives the evidence. It is not open to any court to start with a presumption that extra-judicial confession is a weak type of evidence”

“It would depend on the nature of the circumstances, the time when the confession was made and the credibility of the witnesses who speak to such a confession. Such a confession can be relied upon and conviction can be founded thereon if the evidence about the confession comes from the mouth of witnesses who appear to be unbiased, not even remotely inimical to the accused, and in respect of whom nothing is brought out which may tend to indicate that he may have a motive of attributing an untruthful statement to the accused, the words spoken to by the witness are clear, unambiguous and unmistakably convey that the accused is the perpetrator of the crime and nothing is omitted by the witness which may militate against it. After subjecting the evidence of the witness to a rigorous test on the touchstone of credibility, the extra-judicial confession can be accepted and can be the basis of a conviction if it passes the test of credibility.

Drafted By Abhijit Mishra