Why Information Technology Act Requires Urgent Reform?

By Md. Arif Imam

Published on: January 14, 2024 at 21:49 IST

The beginning of the 21st century marked a significant milestone in India’s technological industry with the enactment of the Information Technology Act in the year 2000. At its core, this legislation aimed to establish a system to govern electronic transactions, communications, and digital signatures.

The very beginning of 21st century the country was stepping into the world of cyberspace, where electronic communication and transactions were gaining momentum. The IT Act of 2000 is a landmark legislation crafted to provide legal recognition and support to these digital interactions. Its primary objectives included facilitating electronic governance, promoting secure electronic transactions, and validating electronic documents.

Amidst the digital transition, the Act served as a foundational pillar, acknowledging the legitimacy of electronic records and digital signatures. It aimed to enhance the trust in electronic communication and transactions while offering a structured legal mechanism for their authentication and validation.

The world witnessed a revolutionary shift in technological paradigms, including the widespread adoption of smartphones, the emergence of social media platforms, the advent of artificial intelligence, and the proliferation of IoT devices[1] transforming the way people communicate, transact, and interact in the digital realm.

These monumental advancements in technology brought forth new challenges and complexities that surpassed the scope of the 2000 Act. The Law, designed to cater to the digital needs of its time, now faces limitations in addressing the multifaceted, dynamics of the contemporary digital ecosystem. As we stand in the middle of this digital evolution, it is important to make reform in the Information Technology Act of 2000 to make it fit for the today’s digitalized era.

The two decades since the enactment of the IT Act 2000 have witnessed an unparalleled evolution in technology, redefining the way individuals, businesses, and governments engage in the digital sphere. This period has been marked by an exponential rise in technological innovations, revolutionizing communication, commerce, and daily life.

The rise of smartphones, the prevalence of high-speed internet, and the integration of technologies such as cloud computing, artificial intelligence, and blockchain have transformed the digital industry. These developments have not only driven connectivity but have also introduced a new array of opportunities and challenges, demanding a reconsideration of current regulatory structures. A big challenge we face is that the rules made for the internet a long time ago don’t quite fit the advanced technology we have today. The Information Technology Act was made when the internet was just starting out in India and now it struggles to cope with the complications that new technologies bring.

Technology has advanced faster than our regulations, highlighting the urgent need for a legal structure that is more flexible and adaptable. The current lack of rules for emerging technologies and evolving digital situations is a barrier to creating a secure, trustworthy, and inclusive digital environment. As we go through this technological shift, the challenge is to close the gap between what the regulations require and the progress in technology. We need a forward-thinking set of laws that not only tackles present issues but also has the ability to adjust to the rapidly changing technological terrain.

The rise of cyber threats has reached unprecedented levels. According to the former Minister of State for Electronics and Information Technology, Rajeev Chandrasekhar, India witnessed 13.91 lakh cybersecurity incidents in 2022. This number, reported by the Indian Computer Emergency Response Team (CERT-In), provides a glimpse into the scale of cyber challenges faced by the country.

It’s important to note that these statistics represent only reported incidents, and the actual extent of cyberattacks on the nation might be more extensive. Despite the large number, there was a slight decrease from the 14.02 lakh incidents recorded in 2021.

The evolution of cyber threats is evident in the rising trend over the years. Government figures reveal that 2.08 lakh incidents were reported in 2018, followed by 3.94 lakh attacks in 2019, and a substantial increase to 11.58 lakh cybersecurity incidents reported to CERT-In in 2020.

In light of these escalating figures, the need to strengthen the legal structure to combat cyber threats becomes even more paramount. The Information Technology Act of 2000, initially visionary in addressing digital challenges, now requires substantial enhancements to effectively tackle the sophisticated nature of contemporary cyber threats.

Strengthening cybersecurity involves a multifaceted approach, including advanced threat intelligence, robust incident response mechanisms, regular security audits, and comprehensive awareness programs. Additionally, the legal system must evolve to incorporate provisions for mandatory cybersecurity standards, data breach notifications, and swift response protocols.

As the country navigates through this era of heightened cyber threats, the imperative to update the IT Act becomes evident. A revised Act should not only address current challenges but also provide the flexibility to adapt to the rapidly changing cyber threat landscape, as reflected in the increasing number of incidents reported each year. This is essential for fostering a secure and resilient digital environment for individuals, businesses, and the government.

Moreover, recent data from the ‘State of Application Security Report’ by Indusface highlights a global surge in cyberattacks, with over a billion attacks reported in Q1 2023. Out of these, more than 500 million cyberattacks were successfully blocked. Concurrently, cybersecurity firm CheckPoint Research revealed an 18% increase in weekly attacks in India during the same period, surpassing the global average increase of 7%. This amounted to an average of 1,248 attacks per week in the country. The Asia Pacific region as a whole experienced a significant year-on-year surge of 16%, reporting an average of 1,835 attacks per week. These figures underscore the urgent need for not only robust cybersecurity measures but also an updated Law to effectively cope with the rise in cyber threats.

In today’s digitally connected world, where personal data is super important, making sure people’s privacy is safe is really, really necessary. The Information Technology Act 2000, made when not everyone’s info was digital, has some difficulties in keeping people’s privacy rights safe. With more and more digital platforms, online stuff, and connected devices, there’s a lot more personal data being made and shared. This includes things like bank details, health records, where you’ve been, and how you behave online all of this needs strong protection to stop it from being misused or accessed without permission. But the current rules don’t cover everything needed to make sure personal data is safe in today’s digital world. There aren’t enough strict rules about how data is collected, stored, processed, and how people give permission for it. This puts people’s privacy at risk in the online world.

Global standards, like the General Data Protection Regulation (GDPR) in the European Union, have set strong rules for protecting data and privacy. These rules say data should be transparent, people need to agree to it being used, only necessary data should be collected, and there should be clear rules for reporting breaches. These standards set a good example for keeping people’s privacy safe online. India needs to follow these global standards, like GDPR, to make sure privacy is protected. The new Digital Personal Data Protection Act, 2023, tries to fix some of these problems by making better rules for data protection. It aims to give people more control over their data and makes those who handle data follow strict rules.

The E-commerce, Consumer Protection, and Digital Transactions
The growth of online shopping has changed how people buy and sell. With more digital transactions happening, we need clear rules to protect consumers and ensure fair and safe online shopping. The rules we have in the Information Technology Act of 2000 helped start the digital economy, but they need updates for today’s online world. To keep online shopping safe, we need simple rules that make sure things are fair, transparent, and protect against fraud. Right now, there aren’t strong enough rules for these things, making it hard to create a safe digital marketplace.

Online shopping comes with challenges like privacy concerns, fraud, and payment security. We need better rules to build trust among people who shop online. Updating the Information Technology Act means making clear rules to protect consumers, keep their data safe, and solve problems that come up in online transactions.

To make online shopping safer, we also need to focus on making e-commerce platforms secure, ensuring payment methods are safe, and having strong checks to prevent fraud. Changes to the law should deal with the details of online shopping, like who is responsible for what, how to solve problems, and keeping people’s data safe in digital transactions.

The Information Technology Act of 2000, though groundbreaking when introduced, has shown several major flaws over the years. These issues highlight the need for a comprehensive overhaul to deal with the challenges posed by today’s digital environment. Some of the significant flaws include:

  1. Outdated Provisions: The Act was enacted over two decades ago, and its provisions haven’t kept up with rapid technological advancements. It fails to address the complexities introduced by contemporary technologies like artificial intelligence and advanced data analytics.
  2. Inadequate Data Protection Measures: The Act lacks strong provisions for data protection, especially given concerns related to privacy and the increase in data breaches. The absence of a defined data storage policy and insufficient metrics for data retention poses a risk to individuals’ privacy.
  3. Vague and Arbitrary Regulations: Certain provisions, particularly those related to censorship and content blocking, are vague and arbitrary. Unclear terms contribute to overreach in state censorship, potentially impacting freedom of speech.
  4. Limited Safeguards Against Surveillance: The framework for interception and monitoring of digital communications lacks adequate safeguards. Broad executive powers without sufficient checks raise concerns about mass surveillance without proper oversight.
  5. Ineffective Measures for Cybersecurity: While the Act defines offenses related to cybersecurity, the institutional mechanisms for incident reporting and response are insufficient. Clearer guidelines and powers for agencies are needed to avoid duplication and disproportionate reporting requirements.
  6. Limited Accountability of Intermediaries: Protections for intermediaries need revisiting as the ‘safe harbour’ provision was introduced when the digital ecosystem was in its infancy. The rise of online harms questions whether a more responsible system is required.
  7. Failure to Address E-commerce Challenges: The Act, initially designed for e-commerce, doesn’t adequately address the complexities of today’s online platforms. Issues like protecting buyers, resolving disputes, and preventing fraud require updated legal provisions.
  8. Emerging Threats: New threats such as deepfakes, AI-driven cyber attacks, and other technological manipulations require legal responses to prevent misuse and harm. Regular updates to the law can help in addressing these emerging threats effectively.
  9. Data Governance and Ownership: With the increasing importance of data in the digital economy, legal frameworks must define and regulate data ownership, access, and usage. This includes establishing clear guidelines on data protection, consent, and accountability for entities handling personal information.
  10. Social Media and Online Platforms: The rise of social media and online platforms introduces new challenges related to user-generated content, misinformation, and digital communication. Legal reforms may be necessary to address issues like online harassment, hate speech, and the responsibilities of platform providers.

Since the technology has rapidly changed how we live and do things. The rules we made in 2000 for the digital world are outdated now. We need new and better rules to protect people’s rights, encourage new ideas, and make a safe digital space. The changes we need cover many things like making digital spaces safe, keeping personal information private, and making sure online shopping is fair. The new rules should align with the emerging cyber threat and Artificial Intelligence. While the government is likely to amend the Information Technology (IT) Rules of 2021 and introduce rules for regulating artificial intelligence (AI) companies and generative AI models, according to people with knowledge of the matter, that remains the much-awaited amendment.

Related Post